Criteria
Excellent
Acceptable
Needs improvement
Content
Grammar
Vocabulary
Spelling and punctuation

You are starting to write but there are some aspects you should be careful. Maybe it is necessary to study again the content section. Not answering or missing information will take points away. You are getting better at writings, unfortunately is not perfect yet. There are some points that you are forgetting about, pay attention to the correct use of past perfect, spelling and punctuation. Very good! Your writing is now acceptable. There is always something that can be corrected but you are certainly answering what is being asked and you have used past perfect correctly. Congratulations!